Hello dear
Welcome To Kenny's Pizza & Subs
At Kenny's Pizza & Subs, nestled in the charming town of McCaysville, GA, culinary passion meets community warmth. This beloved eatery, known for its authentic New York-style pizza, offers a menu that delights with everything from personal-sized cheese pizzas to delectable subs and salads. Customers rave about the mouthwatering cannoli and perfectly seasoned fried scallops. The ambiance, highlighted by friendly service and a vibrant atmosphere, makes every visit memorable. Enthusiasts of hearty flavors can indulge in the Sicilian pizza or the robust double cheeseburger, ensuring there's something for everyone to savor. Experience the culinary charm at Kenny's—it's truly a local gem!
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Garlic Knots
US$4.95Ceaser Salad
US$10.95Ceaser Salad
The Burger
Philly Cheese Bomb
Fried Grouper Sandwich
Shrimp Po Boy
Scallop Po Boy
Italian Sub
About
Kenny's Pizza & Subs
Welcome to Kenny's Pizza & Subs, an unparalleled gem nestled in the charming town of McCaysville, Georgia. Located at 64 Toccoa Ave, this beloved eatery has garnered a loyal following, not just locally but from visitors who travel far and wide in search of the perfect pizza and subs. With a ringing endorsement from customers ranging from fishermen passing through to avid pizza lovers, it’s clear that Kenny’s is a must-visit destination.
The atmosphere at Kenny’s is welcoming and vibrant, making it an ideal spot for families and friends alike. The extensive menu features an impressive array of options that cater to every craving. Here’s a tantalizing selection of what you can expect:
- Pizzas: Renowned for their authentic New York-style pizza, the quality is consistently praised, as noted by fans who travel from Maine to Texas, hoping to relive the delicious experience.
- Subs and Sandwiches: Their offerings extend beyond pizza, featuring delectable choices such as the Philly Cheese Bomb, Fried Grouper Sandwich, and the mouthwatering Italian Sub. Each sandwich is crafted with precision, using high-quality ingredients that shine in every bite.
- Seafood Options: Don’t miss the much-acclaimed Fried Scallop and Shrimp Po Boy. Customers rave about the perfectly cooked scallops, which are lightly breaded and seasoned, creating a dish that's remarkably flavorful.
- Wings and Burgers: The wings are said to be stellar, and for those with a hearty appetite, the Double Cheeseburger promises a mouthwatering experience that won’t soon be forgotten.
- Desserts: Cap off your meal with a classic Cannoli Cake, a sweet treat that perfectly balances the savory flavors of your meal.
Kenny's Pizza & Subs is more than just a restaurant; it's a culinary experience that captures the essence of comfort food. As you step in, the aroma of freshly baked pizza and grilling subs envelops you, enticing you to indulge. The staff prioritizes service, ensuring your dining experience is nothing short of delightful.
The frequent nods to the quality of the food, combined with the warmth of the service, speak volumes about why Kenny's Pizza & Subs has become a cherished spot for both locals and travelers. Plan your visit to this delightful pizza haven, and prepare for a feast that is sure to satisfy your cravings and leave you wanting to return!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Best Pizza joint anywhere, and I've been to them from Maine to Texas. Just as good as Joe's in NY city. When we fly fish this area, we always swing by Kenny's. Wings, Subs, and burgers are very, very good as well. You won't be disappointed. ”
“ Really good NY style pizza. Ordered three pizzas and a salad... All were fantastic. Great service too! ”
“ The pizza and calzone are both excellent. It is across the street from at Blue Ridge Scenic Railway stop in McCaysville. A beautiful little town of McCayville. ”
“ If you want to find a better pizza, go to Italy. This is the best around, hands down. They just started making a Sicilian that made my eyes roll back in my head it's so good. And only try the double cheeseburger if you are ready to go hard in the paint. This thing is made for men who are about their delicious juicy MEAT son. Don't forget napkins... you will need them ”
“ My son and I ate here on Oct. 19, 2024. He got the chicken parm sandwich and I had the fried scallops. The sandwich was awesome! The bread was perfect and the chicken was high quality. The sauce was great. The scallops were ON POINT (just like the music playing on the speakers). They were lightly breaded and nicely seasoned. They were huge, proper sea scallops, and were cooked to absolute perfection. And the portion size was impressive. We will absolutely eat here again next time we're in town. Thank you for such a wonderful meal!! ”
“ Me and my girlfriend visited Kenny’s during our stop on the Blue Ridge Scenic Railway and man...we both agreed it was the best we’ve ever had. We definitely plan on taking a trip up here again just for the pizza! ”
“ The shop itself is rather small but seating is available if needed, I find taking it to go and heading up the road to sit by the river is the perfect solution. Best pizza/burgers/salads, you name it in town. Often rather busy because they are delicious but worth every moments wait and every penny spent. ”
“ Came here from multiple recommendations from people in Ellijay that this was the place for the best burger. It was. It was even said better than River Street Tavern!! My pizza was perfect!!!! ”